AI-powered advertising trademark infringement has quietly become one of the most unresolved legal fault lines in India’s digital economy — and the Delhi High Court’s ruling ordering Google to pay ₹30 lakh in damages to sanitaryware brand Hindware has finally dragged it into the open. What looks like a minor footnote in legal history is, for anyone watching the collision between algorithmic ad targeting and trademark protection, a moment that demands serious attention.
Justice Mini Pushkarna ruled that Google allowed rival companies — Cera and Grohe — to bid on the “HINDWARE” keyword through its erstwhile Google AdWords platform, thereby infringing the brand’s registered trademark. The court permanently restrained Google from enabling similar use of the mark and firmly rejected Google’s claim to intermediary safe harbour protection under the IT Act. The dispute itself dates back over a decade to 2013-2014, but the world it was born into looks nothing like the advertising ecosystem we operate in today.
That gap — between the law that was written and the technology that now runs advertising — is precisely where the perspective of Jaspreet Bindra, cofounder of AI consulting firm AI&Beyond, becomes indispensable. His analysis cuts through the legal jargon to reveal a structural problem that no court ruling, however landmark, can fix on its own.
Jaspreet Bindra’s Core Argument: Intentionality Is Dead
The traditional framework of keyword trademark disputes rests on a foundational concept: intent. When a human advertiser deliberately purchases a competitor’s trademarked brand name as a keyword, the act of infringement is legible. There is a decision-maker, a transaction, and a clear connection between the choice made and the harm caused.
Jaspreet Bindra argues that this framework is being dismantled in real time.
“Trademark infringement through AI-powered matching becomes much more complicated for trademark law,” he said in the Inc42 feature on the Hindware-Google verdict. “Infringement used to have its roots in the advertiser’s purposeful purchase of certain keywords. Now, when AI algorithms decide which keyword will result in an ad, there is less clarity regarding the advertiser’s intentions.”
This is not a technical nuance — it is a structural rupture in how infringement can be proved, prosecuted, and prevented. Bindra’s point cuts to the heart of the problem: in an AI-driven advertising ecosystem, the advertiser may not have knowingly targeted a competitor’s brand at all. A machine-learning system may have made that call autonomously, optimising for performance signals that had nothing to do with conscious competitive targeting.
How Google Ads Changed the Game
To appreciate Bindra’s concern, it helps to understand just how dramatically the advertising machinery has shifted. The Hindware case concerned the old keyword auction model — a relatively transparent system where advertisers actively selected specific terms, set bids, and competed in clearly defined auctions.
Today, that model has been largely superseded by AI-led systems. Google’s Performance Max campaigns, which crossed a million advertiser accounts in early 2025, are a prime example. Advertisers supply business goals, budgets, and creative assets — and Google’s machine learning then determines which queries, audiences, and placements are most likely to drive results. The system analyses user intent, browsing behaviour, device type, location, and historical performance to optimise campaigns in real time.
Under this paradigm, an advertiser running a Performance Max campaign may never explicitly select the keyword “HINDWARE.” Yet if Google’s AI determines that users searching for Hindware are likely to convert for a competing sanitaryware brand, it could serve that ad autonomously. Who is responsible then? The advertiser who never chose the keyword? The platform whose algorithm made the call?
This is the accountability gap that Jaspreet Bindra is pointing at — and it has no clear answer in India’s current legal framework.
The Ghost of Old Keyword Battles
Bindra’s concern is not hypothetical. India has already seen how these cases play out — and the picture is far from settled. MakeMyTrip took Google and Booking.com to court in 2022, alleging that competitors were buying its trademarked keywords to divert search traffic.
An initial ruling favoured MakeMyTrip, but that was overturned on appeal, and in March 2024 the Supreme Court dismissed the online travel agency’s plea. In 2023, Policybazaar’s petition to restrain keyword use on Google AdWords was similarly rejected by the Delhi High Court.
These cases followed the old model — human-directed keyword purchases. The Hindware ruling, while also rooted in the traditional keyword framework, lands at a moment when that model is already becoming obsolete. As Bindra observes, the legal system is being asked to adjudicate a question that the technology has already moved past.
The irony is pointed: courts are still debating whether deliberate keyword purchases constitute trademark infringement while the advertising platforms have quietly shifted to systems where no deliberate keyword purchase may occur at all.
AI Advertising, Intent, and the Accountability Vacuum
Bindra’s intervention in this debate is significant because it frames the issue not as a legal technicality but as a fundamental challenge to how we assign responsibility in AI-driven systems.
When a human makes a decision, accountability is straightforward. When an algorithm makes thousands of targeting decisions per second across millions of campaigns, accountability becomes diffuse. This is the deeper implication of what Bindra is raising: AI-powered advertising trademark infringement is not just a harder version of the old problem — it is a categorically different problem.
The advertiser may not have intended to target the trademarked keyword. The platform’s AI optimised based on performance data. The consumer sees a competitor’s ad when searching for a known brand. The harm is real; the chain of intentional decision-making is broken. Existing trademark law, which was built around the concept of deliberate, purposeful use of a mark, struggles to accommodate this reality.
Google’s own response to such concerns — that advertisers can use negative keywords and brand exclusions to prevent their ads from appearing against competitor brand terms — places the burden squarely on the advertiser. But this assumes a level of active oversight that many smaller advertisers, running automated campaigns, may not exercise.
The default behaviour of AI systems, absent explicit restrictions, is to maximise reach — and that maximisation may routinely cross trademark lines that the human advertiser was never even aware of.
What Happens When Ads Move Into AI Platforms?
Bindra’s concern gains additional urgency when viewed against the incoming wave of advertising on AI platforms themselves. OpenAI has announced that ads are coming to ChatGPT, with assurances around clear labelling and privacy focus. Perplexity briefly pursued advertising before pulling back. Meanwhile, as Inc42 noted, Anthropic has confirmed that Claude will remain ad-free.
This migration of advertising into AI-native environments introduces an entirely new layer of complexity. When an AI chatbot answers a user’s question about the best sanitaryware brand and surfaces a competitor’s name through what appears to be an organic recommendation — but is in fact the result of a commercial arrangement — who has infringed the trademark? The brand that paid? The AI platform that surfaced the response? The model that generated it?
These are not remote, theoretical questions. They are the inevitable next frontier of the trademark disputes that the Hindware-Google verdict has now brought into sharp focus. And as Bindra’s framing makes clear, the law is not ready for them.
The Road Ahead: Regulation Must Catch Up
Jaspreet Bindra’s perspective points toward a conclusion that many legal and AI experts are beginning to share: India’s trademark and advertising law needs to be substantially updated to account for the realities of AI-powered advertising.
The existing framework, shaped by cases like Hindware, MakeMyTrip, and Policybazaar, was built around human decision-making. It asks who chose the keyword. It looks for the advertiser’s intent. It assigns liability based on traceable human action. None of these assumptions hold cleanly in a world where machine learning systems make autonomous targeting decisions at scale.
What is needed — and what Bindra’s framing implicitly calls for — is a new legal architecture that addresses platform accountability in AI-driven advertising, establishes standards for auditability of how AI systems map advertiser inputs to placements, and creates clearer obligations around default behaviours that could facilitate AI-powered advertising trademark infringement without any deliberate choice by the advertiser.
The ₹30 lakh fine on Google may be trivial in financial terms. But the questions it has surfaced — questions that Jaspreet Bindra has articulated with particular clarity — are anything but trivial. As AI continues to reshape how advertising works, the Hindware-Google verdict may well be remembered as the moment India was forced to confront the accountability gap at the heart of algorithmic advertising.